US worries Russia returning to authoritarian past

[wanna be drummer]

Originally Posted by Joe Castro

Thats because your troops are by definition guilty. They are tools of imperialism. AL Qaeda members dont have a uniform, they don't carry some kind of AQ identity card. For all we know you are just lifting completely people at random - the British boys were no terrorists. This we know is not the case of any US prisoners that may be taken.

Your serious...?


What a tool

[Joe Castro]

Originally Posted by wanna be drummer

Your serious...?


What a tool

You want to challenge my words or trade insults ?

[wanna be drummer]

Originally Posted by Joe Castro

You want to challenge my words or trade insults ?

You would say that a U.S. soldier deserves what he gets as punishment from Iraqi insurgents or an Al Qaeda terrorist, etc. and you honestly think thats a legitimate argument?


And yet you had a Che Guevar avatar...well as long as he wasn't an "Imperialist tool," I suppose he must've been grand huh?

[Joe Castro]

Originally Posted by wanna be drummer

You would say that a U.S. soldier deserves what he gets as punishment from Iraqi insurgents or an Al Qaeda terrorist, etc. and you honestly think thats a legitimate argument?

That's not what i said. Just bcause you can't challenge my words doesn't mean you ahould have to make some up for me.

Originally Posted by wanna be drummer

And yet you had a Che Guevar avatar...well as long as he wasn't an "Imperialist tool," I suppose he must've been grand huh?

I honestly have no idea what relevence Che has to any of this.

[wanna be drummer]

Originally Posted by Joe Castro

That's not what i said. Just bcause you can't challenge my words doesn't mean you ahould have to make some up for me.

Directly...perhaps not. Was it hinted? I think so.

Thats honestly how it came off.

I honestly have no idea what relevence Che has to any of this.

You criticize America (for good reason sometimes I'm sure). You criticize American "technically guilty"soldiers. Yet you glorify Che Guevara...hmm

[Joe Castro]

Originally Posted by wanna be drummer

You criticize America (for good reason sometimes I'm sure). You criticize American "technically guilty"soldiers. Yet you glorify Che Guevara...hmm

Well you can hardly compare a soldier in an aggressive, invading army with a liberator, politician and theorist.

I admire his acts as a human being and his contribution to socialist theory more so than the revolutionary activities.

My main point stands anyway. We all know who an American soldier is, given where they are and they are in uniform. Those in Guantanamo are not so easily identifiable.

[wanna be drummer]

Originally Posted by Joe Castro

Well you can hardly compare a soldier in an aggressive, invading army with a liberator, politician and theorist.

You mean:
A grunt part of a large occupying force vs. a guerilla/terrorist who was widely known as a ruthless butcher

I admire his acts as a human being and his contribution to socialist theory more so than the revolutionary activities.

I agree that he was very dedicated to his marxist beliefs and i think he legitimately wanted good change in the world (same with Lenin). My problem is not with his ideals but how he went about acheiving them.

[/quote]My main point stands anyway. We all know who an American soldier is, given where they are and they are in uniform. Those in Guantanamo are not so easily identifiable.[/quote]
Agreed to an extent